What is the best way to get out of a catch 22 situation, especially when it decides the future of two individuals?
Naina was sitting next to the phone, her face hidden behind her palms. She was sitting in this position from the last 4 hours, deciding whether to make the call or not. Either way the loss was her. She was cursing today’s unfateful morning when she got the devastating news. She felt as if her legs were too frail and thin to support her weight and she just tripped over. She lay there for a few seconds and then gathered all her strength to somehow place her body over the couch. Since then 4 hours had passed sitting in the same position. She picked up the receiver, still unsure about her decision, and dialled a number.
He was sitting next to the phone waiting for her call. He was cursing today’s unfateful morning when he came to know that someone had told her everything she was not supposed to know. He was sure that she will call him so he was sitting next to the phone since morning. A lot of time had passed and there was no sign of her call. But he can wait a few more hours. All he was supposed to do was to wait, watching the red coloured phone with shiny white buttons. Anytime this red plastic could ring to life bringing with it the message of his survival, but the negative was also possible. All he could do was waiting and he was doing this patiently.
The number was undoubtedly his because she had dialled it without seeing in her diary and there was only one phone number in the world which she had ever memorised.
He picked up as soon as the phone rang.
“Aman?” she asked in her usually sweet voice.
“Who else it could be, Naina”
“Funny. I called to say um........”
“I know, I know. Suvrat told me everything in the morning. So....what do you have to say?”
Naina paused for a while, closed her eyes to search for an appropriate sentence, and said nothing when she found out that the courage to start such a discussion was missing.
Aman somehow understood this and decided to carry on the conversation all by himself.
“You know Naina; first of all I am sorry for all the mess I have put you in.”
“It’s not just a mess Aman and you know that very well. It’s a matter of life and death for people.”
“Yeah I know that. But you tell me just one thing, what wrong have I done?”
“You knew all of it from the beginning Aman, you just never told me.”
“I don’t think that it is some kind of crime to not tell you about people you do not love. Or is it? Look he loved you but you never looked at him in that way. There are many people in this little world who may have loved you; many of them may have even wanted to marry you. But the point is that you never loved them and that is why they are insignificant for our relation. You love me and I love you, as simple as that.”
“He was your friend Aman, your best friend, how can you propose to a girl whom your friend loves. Does your conscience allow you to do so? Just ask yourself once”.
“I already thought Naina, I’ve been thinking over it from the last one year and the conclusion with which I came out is that this is my true love for you, so nothing surpasses it.”
“Not even your best friend? Huh?”
“It’s not like that Naina. Just think practically. Is there any rule written that I shall not love the girl whom my friend loves, even if she does not love him?”
Naina closed his eyes once again, tightly this time.
“I need a second.”
“Ok, I’ll hold.”
She put the receiver down on the table, to the left of the phone. Aman was waiting; all sorts of thoughts were flooding his mind.
She sank into the chair, rested her elbows on the table and palms on her forehead. She began to think, all kinds of memories zoomed past before her still closed eyes. And there he was, Manas. He was always the kind of boy girls never liked to talk to. Every day he came to school with his hair oiled copiously, combed straight and he always curled up in the front corner seat. His only friend was Aman, a good looking, smart boy. None of their personalities matched but still they were best friends. Naina, Aman and Manas were classmates and with time she became the third member of their small group.
Naina used to be a little shy girl during her school days, intelligence had always impressed her and Manas had much of it. So it was just a matter of time that they got close. Although Manas appeared to be boring guy, he had got all necessary skills to cheer people up even in very bad mood. So as their friendship strengthened Naina found her life happier, more promising and full of opportunities. But she never knew that he loved her.
She woke up from her sleep of memories and found the receiver waiting for her. She picked it up; Aman was still there, waiting. He loved her, no doubt.
“See Aman I need to talk to Manas....right now. Can you pick me up please?”
Aman hung up without saying a word.
After 5 minutes or so, Aman was waiting outside her house in his car.
“Thanks for coming Aman.”
“Naina....uh.....are you sure? I mean is this necessary?”
She chose to remain silent.
All the way up to Manas’s home both of them said nothing. Tension in the air was clearly visible. A day before, they used to be the most talkative couple in college.’
When they stopped, she broke the silence, “I’m sorry Aman but I need to do this.”
He understood,” It’s Ok, I’ll wait here. Go ahead”
Aman didn’t had the slightest idea of what she was going to do.
Manas was sitting on a rocking chair in his room, lights all off. He was visible due to the faint light which came in through the door where Naina was standing. He turned back to see who was at the door. He saw a silhouette, he saw Naina. A shiver came down his spine for a second. But in the next, his gloom doubled. Strange was this feeling when one simultaneously experienced both extremities of human emotion.
They stared into each others’ eyes for a moment, trying to talk through them.
“Naina please don’t say anything. I just want you to be happy and I don’t care whether you are with me or anyone else.......Please Naina.”
She came close to him, he stood and they were face to face. She slapped him hard in the face.
“All these years......all these years you.....you just never had the courage, huh”, she turned around and sobbed. He kept his hand on her shoulder and she quickly gave a jerk to remove it.
“Naina......”
“Please don’t say anything, please. You have said and done enough to ruin my life. Why didn’t you just say it?”
“I always wanted you to be free to choose. You chose Aman and that’s it. I stand nowhere in the story.”
“So you can now read my mind, hmm? How do you know that Aman was my first choice.....how do you know that it wasn’t you?”
“Because it just can’t be me. I don’t fit anywhere.”
She looked into his eyes and said,
“It was you Manas......always”, and then there was the damned silence.
Manas looked at her in disbelief. He looked deep into her eyes, two tears rolled down her cheek. She moved her lips to say something but failing to do so, turned her back to him and wept.
He was still shocked, not sure about what he had just heard. All those school days zoomed past his eyes. He remembered the first day when Aman had introduced them. She was a sweet, cute girl with astonishing blue eyes. It was love at first sight and love for a lifetime.
“I don’t believe you Naina, it maybe just out of sympathy for me, I mean it may be.....”
She turned around,” Don’t believe me? What do you mean? You were the one who taught me how to live one’s life like a real life which others can only crave for. You were the only one whom I liked talking to after witnessing all those family fights. And you say you don’t believe me? I confided in you Manas.”
“But Naina things are different now. You love Aman and he loves you. Isn’t it?”
Naina was dumbstruck; she had forgotten about Aman for a while. Although Manas was her first love, she was with Aman now. Aman who loved her more than anything in the world, who would leave everything for her, who would turn the world upside down just for one smile of hers. She cannot betray him. Once again the ghastly silence prevailed.
A third voice broke the silence, “No it isn’t so.”
It was Aman standing at the door.
“Forgive me Manas, if it’s possible”, he said and left.
Manas tried to say something but Aman was already gone.
Naina was truly shocked. In a moment she was left with nothing. Manas would not accept him because she and Aman were together. And Aman will feel guilty all his life for unknowingly betraying his best friend. Her happy life had turned into a pile of cinders, waiting to get blown away.
She looked at Manas; he was already so much shocked today to say anything more. He was sitting in his rocking chair, staring blankly into the ceiling.
She left quietly and he said nothing to stop her.
All the way back to her home she kept thinking about a solution. When she finally reached her home, she had made up her mind. The root cause of the devastation of their lives was just one- she herself. So it was time to end her useless life. She didn’t think about the consequences, just picked up the bottle of sleeping pills and emptied it on her palm. And then.....her phone rang.
It was Aman.
“I’m sorry Naina, I never knew. You should have told me. I’d never have bothered you people.”
“Don’t be sorry Aman. It’s all my fault. I just need some time to.......”
“Bye Naina......I love you.”
“Aman......”, but he had hung up.
She felt something. Something was not right. He dialled Aman’s number. The phone rang and rang, there was no reply.
She ran out of her house and rushed to Aman’s place. When she reached there, the door was ajar. She stepped inside calling his name.
She reached his bedroom. Aman lay on his bed, peacefully. His lifeless hand hung from one corner of the bed with a bottle clutched in its palm.
Naina dropped on her knees and cried like a child. Aman’s decision of a lifetime had cost him his life.